Dishonest people are usually the loudest
ones trying to convince others that they are honest. Is it the same story with states? Every state in the world
claims that they are free and safe democracies.
Only 4 countries in the world officially admit that they are not democracies. Can you tell which 4 countries officially admit that they are not democracies?
Only 4 countries in the world officially admit that they are not democracies. Can you tell which 4 countries officially admit that they are not democracies?
Find the answer at the end of this article. (Disclaimer: I am not suggesting that these 4 countries are honest, while others are not!)
Photo source: Screen capture from here
Importing democracy has been a political fashion in the last few years.
Time will tell how it succeeds. Democracy
is however, only one form of government. There are many others currently in use
around the world. Historically, many countries e.g., China and Russia have
experimented with different types of governments in their glorious past. Some
have worked better than others.
What works when depends on a lot of
factors and typically we are always wiser in hindsight. Despotic, liberal,
monarchy, democracy, sultanate - these are some of the different political
systems of government that can be found in the world. If we look at the types
of governments found in the world today, we shall see some unusual ones like kritarchy too.
Types
of Governments Found around the World
Ethnocracy –
Hitler’s dream for the thousand-year-Reich! One ethnic group dominates the
state and its mechanisms and the government is explicit in its aims to serve
the interests of this solitary ethnic group e.g., Israel.
Ochlocracy – Mob
rule or absence of clear authority. One of the only definitions political
theorists agree on about what is a state – the monopoly of the use of violence,
is not often valid in such cases. E.g., Libya after the toppling of Gaddafi.
Plutocracy – A
small group of the wealthiest citizens have practically all the power.
Historically Italian seafaring merchant states such as Genoa, Venice were
plutocracies. The City of London (the financial district, not the whole city)
has 450, 000 non-resident well-off financial employee non-resident voters
decide things there rather than the 9 000 residents. Some people consider USA
to be behaving like a plutocracy.
Kritarchy – Rule
by judges. Ancient Israel described in the Book of the Judges (1380-1050 B.C.).
Currently only Somalia is ruled by the Islamic Courts Union but Palestinian
courts have women judges also.
Oligarchy – Power
rests effectively in the hands of a tiny group of elite people. Some people
consider South Africa in the 20th century (especially during
Apartheid) and modern Russia, with about 40 oligarchs
owning more than $1 billion as examples of oligarchy.
Stratocracy – Rule
by military chiefs. This is
different from military dictatorship, which illegally usurps power. In
stratocracy, military leaders fill all the important posts. Whether society
sanctions this without coercion, is entirely a different matter. Myanmar or
Burma is an example.
Bureaucracy –
Non-elected officials rule the state, usually because elected politicians are
not able to form a government. Bureaucrats ran the Netherlands (a
constitutional monarchy otherwise) for 207 days in 1977, without an elected
government. Iraq eventually broke this record of modern times in 2010.
Theocracy –
Government by people who are regarded by followers of a faith as divinely
guided. The Vatican is an example. The CIA considers Iran to be a Theocratic Republic. Some people allege
that the US state of Utah is a theocracy
as 90% of the state legislature and 80% of the judiciary
are Mormons.
Ergatocracy –
Another name for a communist state or rule by the working class. Early Soviet
Union could be considered an example.
Exilarchy –
Basically a government in exile. The Tibetan government in exile in India, and the Biafran Government in Exile are examples.
Diarchy – Rule by
two equal heads of states sharing power. Ancient Rome had consuls sharing power. The only current example is Andorra with two
co-princes sharing power until death. One of the princes is the sitting
President of France, currently François Hollande.
Kleptocracy –
Basically a plutocracy, but the leader or leaders are solely focused on
embezzling almost all the money available. A good example would
be the rule of Mobutu, King of the
African country of Zaire.
Zaire dictator MobutuSese Seko Kuku Ngbendu wa Za Banga with US President Nixon
Meritocracy –
Usually used in connection with workplaces. Some strong rulers have used
meritocracy to differentiate their rule from aristocratic and inherited power
systems preceding them. Genghis Khan in the Mongol Empire and Napoleon, in his
early days are old examples. Today only Singapore officially claims to be a
meritocracy.
President of Singapore Tony Tan Keng Yam Photo source:
President of Singapore Tony Tan Keng Yam Photo source:
Timocracy – Rule
by property owners and by people who have a strong love of honour. Early United
States could be considered as an example.
Monarchy – Rule by
a hereditary monarch. We have basically two kinds of monarchy: constitutional monarchy, where the
monarch stays in the ceremonial role and does not interfere with elected rulers
like the prime minister and parliament as in the UK. The other kind is absolute monarchy or autocracy as in
Brunei, who is called the Sultan of Brunei. Absolute monarchs can also be
elected as the Pope in Vatican is. Monarchy is not so common in the world today compared to the 19th and early 20th centuries. Currently there are 44 countries with a monarch as a head of state (16 of these are commonwealth realms).
Democracy – This
can be direct democracy, where
citizens personally take part in decision-making as in the Swiss cantons of
Glarus and Appenzell Innerhoden in Switzerland or representative democracy, or representative
democracy e.g., UK.
The people in Appenzell Innerhoden are proud to report that this institution of Landsgemeinde has been working since 1378, though the original paper deed recording the foundation is missing now.
The people in Appenzell Innerhoden are proud to report that this institution of Landsgemeinde has been working since 1378, though the original paper deed recording the foundation is missing now.
Answer:
In case you tried to guess like me, North
Korea is a wrong answer. Officially that country is called the Democratic
People’s Republic of Korea. The 4 countries are Brunei, Burma, Saudi Arabia and
the Vatican.
2 comments:
Fascinating post and well, so many types of powers...
Extremely informative, dear Rana. You are so right the French President has the title of Co-Prince of Andorra and also Canon of the Lateran and Saint-Jean-de-Maurienne.
Merry Christmas, brother!
Love,
François
I live in Singapore, this is a very efficient type of government. Nice information.
Post a Comment